Religion News Service: In-depth. Impartial. Engaged.

Politics » Law & Court

Court says Catholic businessman can fight contraception mandate

ST. LOUIS  (RNS) A federal appeals court on Wednesday (Nov. 28) temporarily blocked the enforcement of the Obama administration's contraception mandate while a Catholic business owner appeals a lower court's ruling that tossed out his suit.

Show Caption |

A federal appeals court on Wednesday (Nov. 28) temporarily blocked the enforcement of the Obama administration's contraception mandate while a Catholic business owner appeals a lower court's ruling that tossed out his suit. Credit: RNS photo courtesy Shutterstock (http://www.shutterstock.com/cat.mhtml?searchterm=contraception&search;_group=&lang=en&search_source=search_form#id=48504880). *Note: This image is not available to download

Opponents of the law said that it was the first time that an appeals court had weighed in on the issue, which has spawned multiple suits across the country, and called it a “significant victory.”

“The order sends a message that the religious beliefs of employers must be respected by the government,” said Francis Manion, senior counsel of the American Center for Law and Justice, one of the lawyers representing Frank O'Brien.

In a two-sentence order issued Wednesday, a three-judge panel of the St. Louis-based 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals voted 2-1 to grant O'Brien's company a delay while the appeal is heard.

O'Brien Industrial Holdings and O'Brien, a devout Catholic, sued the federal government in March, alleging the contraception mandate that's part of the 2010 health care reform law would force him to choose between his moral and religious beliefs and possibly face stiff fines.

The law requires coverage of prescription birth control pills and implants in all private health insurance policies, starting in 2013.

A lower court ruled in late September that the health care law does “not impose a 'substantial burden' on either Frank O'Brien" or his company, or violate their rights.

At the time, the law's opponents said the lower court ruling was the first on the law's merits among 30 similar suits.

After O'Brien's suit was tossed out by a lower court, his lawyers asked for an expedited appeal.

O'Brien's company includes several businesses that process ceramic materials, and the charitable St. Nicholas Fund.

(Robert Patrick writes for the St. Louis Post-Dispatch).

KRE/AMB END PATRICK

Topics: Politics, Law & Court
Beliefs: Christian - Catholic
Tags: 8th u.s. circuit court of appeals, american center for law and justice, birth control, catholic, contraception mandate, frank o'brien, obamacare

You must acquire rights to repost our content. Log in now for permission to download and reprint or repost this article.

Related Stories

Did Isaiah really predict the Virgin birth?

(RNS) A new Catholic translation of the Bible tweaks an Old Testament text -- Isaiah 7:14 -- that many Christians consider a prophecy about Jesus’ birth. So, why did they alter a 2,745-year-old prophecy, and does it change what the church teaches about Jesus’ virgin birth? By Daniel Burke.
More | Comments (7)

The sacred ran through jazz legend Dave Brubeck’s music

RNS) Jazz legend Dave Brubeck was best known in the secular jazz world for his startling compositions using different time signatures. Religion, however, was never far from Brubeck’s creative mind -- or his inspiration. By David E. Anderson.
More | Comments (2)

Poll: Most Americans say employers should cover contraception

(RNS) Most Americans believe employers -- even religious ones -- should provide contraception coverage for their employees, according to a new survey by LifeWay Research. By Daniel Burke.
More | Comments (11)

Retiree devoted to mission: repairing damaged rosaries

SIMSBURY, Conn. (RNS) At age 75, Betty Holden in on a crusade to repair broken rosaries. She's been at it for almost 20 years, spending several hours a day behind a pair of needle-nose pliers. By Ann Marie Somma.
More | Comments (0)

New book tries to dispel the “Black Legend” of the papacy’s most scandalous dynasty

VATICAN CITY (RNS) With hundreds of movies and novels devoted to their crimes and intrigues, the Borgias are probably the most controversial family in the history of the papacy. But a new book, drawing on documents from the Vatican Secret Archive, tries to cast the Renaissance dynasty in a new light and dispel the "black legend" surrounding it. By Alessandro Speciale
More | Comments (1)

Sign In



Forgot Password?

You also can sign in with Facebook or Twitter if you've connected your account to them.

Sign In Using Facebook

Sign In Using Twitter