Religion News Service: In-depth. Impartial. Engaged.

Politics » Election

Sister Simone Campbell, ‘Nun from the Bus,’ rips Republicans at Democratic convention

Video courtesy the Democratic National Convention (2012)

(RNS) Paul Ryan has been taking a lot of heat over the factual accuracy of claims he made in his prime time address at the Republican convention last week, but Wednesday night at the Democratic confab the GOP vice-presidential candidate – and practicing Catholic – was schooled by a popular nun on the moral shortcomings of his budget proposals.

“Paul Ryan claims this budget reflects the principles of our shared faith,” Sister Simone Campbell, who became a celebrity of sorts this summer when she led the national “Nuns on the Bus” tour for social justice, told cheering Democratic delegates in Charlotte.

“But the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops stated that the Ryan budget failed a basic moral test, because it would harm families living in poverty,” Campbell said.

“We agree with our bishops, and that's why we went on the road: to stand with struggling families and to lift up our Catholic sisters who serve them. Their work to alleviate suffering would be seriously harmed by the Romney-Ryan budget, and that is wrong.”

By framing her critique in the context of her Christian faith, Campbell was directly challenging the Republicans in the kind of religious language that has been a hallmark of the GOP’s campaign to rally believers behind Mitt Romney and Ryan.

Show Caption | | Details

Sister Simone Campbell addresses an audience Monday July 2, 2012 to concluded the Nuns on the Bus tour. Credit: RNS photo by Chris Lisee

But she also sought to identify the sisters and the Democratic agenda with Catholic tradition at a time when Catholic voters – who comprise close to one-quarter of the electorate – are considered key to the November election.

Just as important, Campbell neatly folded her remarks in with statements from the Catholic hierarchy, which has had more than its share of disagreements with President Obama and the Democratic Party over issues like gay marriage and abortion.

Campbell did not address those hot-button issues directly, but she did defend Obama’s health care reform law as a cause she considers “part of my pro-life stance and the right thing to do.”

“In Cincinnati, I met Jini, who had just come from her sister's memorial service,” Campbell said in one of several anecdotes she related from the summer bus tour of nine states. “When Jini's sister Margaret lost her job, she lost her health insurance. She developed cancer and had no access to diagnosis or treatment. She died unnecessarily. That is tragic. And it is wrong.”

Like many other speakers so far, Campbell underscored the plight of poor and working class Americans in the recession, and pointed to Democratic policies as both the most effective answer, and the most moral one.

“During our journey, I rediscovered a few truths,” Campbell said. “First, Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan are correct when they say that each individual should be responsible. But their budget goes astray in not acknowledging that we are responsible not only for ourselves and our immediate families. Rather, our faith strongly affirms that we are all responsible for one another.”

“I am my sister's keeper. I am my brother's keeper,” she said in one of several lines that drew rousing applause.

Here is the text of Campbell's remarks:

Good evening, I'm Sister Simone Campbell, and I'm one of the "nuns on the bus." So, yes, we have nuns on the bus. And a nun on the podium!

Let me explain why I'm here. In June, I joined other Catholic sisters on a 2,700-mile bus journey through nine states to tell Americans about the budget Congressman Paul Ryan wrote and Governor Romney endorsed.

Paul Ryan claims his budget reflects the principles of our shared Catholic faith. But the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops stated that the Ryan budget failed a basic moral test, because it would harm families living in poverty.

We agree with our bishops, and that's why we went on the road: to stand with struggling families and to lift up our Catholic sisters who serve them. Their work to alleviate suffering would be seriously harmed by the Romney-Ryan budget, and that is wrong.

During our journey, I rediscovered a few truths. First, Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan are correct when they say that each individual should be responsible. But their budget goes astray in not acknowledging that we are responsible not only for ourselves and our immediate families. Rather, our faith strongly affirms that we are all responsible for one another.

I am my sister's keeper. I am my brother's keeper. While we were in Toledo, I met 10-year-old twins Matt and Mark, who had gotten into trouble at school for fighting. Sister Virginia and the staff at the Padua Center took them in when they were suspended and discovered on a home visit that these 10-year-olds were trying to care for their bedridden mother who has MS and diabetes.

They were her only caregivers. The sisters got her medical help and are giving the boys some stability. Now the boys are free to claim much of the childhood they were losing. Clearly, we all share responsibility for the Matts and Marks in our nation.

In Milwaukee, I met Billy and his wife and two boys at St. Benedict's dining room. Billy's work hours were cut back in the recession. Billy is taking responsibility for himself and his family, but right now without food stamps, he and his wife could not put food on their family table.

We all share responsibility for creating an economy where parents with jobs earn enough to take care of their families. In order to cut taxes for the very wealthy, the Romney-Ryan budget would make it even tougher for hard-working Americans like Billy to feed their families. Paul Ryan says this budget is in keeping with the moral values of our shared faith. I disagree.

In Cincinnati, I met Jini, who had just come from her sister's memorial service. When Jini's sister Margaret lost her job, she lost her health insurance. She developed cancer and had no access to diagnosis or treatment. She died unnecessarily. And that is tragic. And it is wrong.

The Affordable Care Act will cover people like Margaret. We all share responsibility to ensure that this vital health care reform law is properly implemented and that all governors, all governors, expand Medicaid coverage so no more Margarets die from lack of care. This is part of my pro-life stance and the right thing to do.

I have so many other stories but let me tell you one more. In Hershey, Pennsylvania, a woman in her late thirties approached us. She asked for the names of some people she could talk to, because she felt alone and isolated. Her neighbors have been polarized by politics masquerading as values. She cares about the well-being of the people in her community.

She wishes they, and the rest of the nation, would listen to one another with kindness and compassion. Listen to one another rather than yell at each other. I told her then, and I tell her now, that she is not alone.

Looking out at you tonight, I feel your presence combined with that of the thousands of caring people we met on our journey. Together, we understand that an immoral budget that hurts already struggling families does not reflect our nation's values. We are better than that.

So I urge you, I urge you, join us on the bus. Join us as together we stand with Matt and Mark, Billy and his family, the woman in Hershey and the Margarets of our nation.

This is what we nuns on the bus are all about: We care for the 100 percent, and that will secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our nation. So join us as we nuns and all of us drive for faith, family and fairness.
 

Topics: Politics, Election
Beliefs: Christian - Catholic
Tags: barack obama, budget, catholic bishops, catholic social teaching, democratic national convention, democrats, mitt romney, nuns on the bus, paul ryan, republicans, sister simone campbell, social justice

David Gibson

David Gibson is an award-winning religion journalist, author and filmmaker. He writes for RNS and until recently covered the religion beat for AOL's Politics Daily. He blogs at Commonweal magazine, and has written two books on Catholic topics, the latest a biography of Pope Benedict XVI.
View Author Profile

Subscribe to This Blog

You must acquire rights to repost our content. Log in now for permission to download and reprint or repost this article.

Comments

  1. Sister Simone speaks here about social issues, especially the issue of poverty. People on both sides have different ideas on how the problem of poverty can be approached. The problem with Sr. Simone’s appearance as a speaker at the Democratic Convention is it “implies” that the Catholic Church supports the platform of the Democratic Party. It does not. It is very sad to say that the Democratic Party is promoting the culture of death. That was made very clear last night after listening to Sandra Flukes speech.

    Yes - the issue of poverty is a LIFE issue of great importance. But the issue of ABORTION, which is murder, trumps all other issues.

    Sister is only a sister by the good graces of the Church. She should defend all that the Church teaches. She should have mentioned clearly the grave danger of a party platform that promotes the killing of the unborn.

  2. So sad, but they say the Devil can quote the Bible to suit his case. . Jesus must weep and His Mother feel sad that one of His Brides selectively rejects what His Gospel says.

  3. Talk about a “cafeteria Catholic”! Sr. Campbell criticizes Romney-Ryan on hypothetical budget issues, but has no moral problem with the anti-Catholic agenda of the Obama-Biden administration (abortion, gay marriage, government mandates on private religious institutions, etc.). What a hypocrite!

  4. It’s too bad that Sister has been used as a pawn in the game of politics, especially on a national stage…who is advising her? where is her spiritual adviser. To also, so to speak, give the nod, that Catholics are for the democrats - a promoter of Godlessness (secularism and atheism) and a planned parenthood owned party at tax payers expense (half billion $$$) - is another twisted notion. 

    This Sister has cast hersef as a democrat, the same party that deleted God from its` platform (and then flip-flopped) and had a head line speaker from the national abortion rights association - when obama said abortion should be rare.

    We are witnessing, lies, deceipt, twisted speech, and confusion right out in the open.
    God help us.

    Pray to and rely on God - The Holy Trinity.

     

  5. I think this nun should we removed from the church. Since when does the Catholic church let nun campaign. I do not believe this.

  6. Notice that Sister campbell did not mention how we should address the now $16 trillion deficit. Shwe also didn’t mention how to address the underlying causes of poverty i.e. out-of-wedlocj birth, single-parenting, separation and divorce, school dropouts, illiteracy, illegal immigration, lack of respect for authority, lack of self-control and self-discipline, etc.  I wonder what a Sister Campbell budget proposal would look like? Is a $20 trillion deficit okay with her?  She has her head in the sand like so many other liberal activists. She has no business representing the entire Catholic church with her partisan comments.

  7. Real nice, people. Your opinion of us simple “bleeding hearts” is clear. I don’t know if any of you are Catholic yourselves, but forget about theology: Simple lack of compassion will continue to repel me and my godless family from your stingy, hateful congregations.

    Meanwhile, you all and the U.S. bishops make it sound like the Devil gave us brains: Apparently, our soft-hearted women religious are similarly afflicted!

    You foetus-lovers make a pretty picture, too, waiting around outside Planned Parenthood to kick a girl when she’s down and block her access to what little hope and refuge she may seek under what are obviously sad circumstances for all involved. I have difficulty understanding those who claim to be “spiritual” and set mere biology over the human spirit, who offer no love or knowledge to children always struggling to make their way in our world.

    If “the least of these” does not mean a desperate, knocked-up girl, I don’t know what it means. Zygotes, maybe? Zygotes and embryos are fascinating things, and the unknowable human potential those cells-then-tissues-then-organisms represent merits our respect and humility, but I dare say, I feel my obligation to the present reality of a thinking, feeling girl is far greater than to any representative of human potential.

    Some of you might argue Jesus said, “Love one another,” but forgot to add sensible qualifications like, “At least those who are Godly and well-mannered, and not to such an extent that you jeopardize your own financial well-being.” Or maybe “love” has a special, technical meaning for Christians, and all the evil we do each other in this world—most readily achieved through neglect and thoughtlessness—is made up for by the Christian “love” and “faith” buried in our hearts.

    How convenient! Our consciences thus assuaged, it ought to be easy to balance the budget with some “tough” and “courageous” policies (sensus Romney & Ryan). After all, God didn’t make us the 7th richest nation in the world just for us to turn around and waste it, mollycoddling the sick, poor, and otherwise unproductive, now did He?

  8. Matthew,
    Give it a rest already!
    Must be so exhausting to carry all that bitterness inside!
    I’ll pray for you, Lord knows you need a lot of those!

  9. Thanks, Lisa…I think….

    I consider myself better off than most, besides the big chip on my shoulder….

    You’re certainly not required to share my concerns, and perhaps you have bigger fish to fry that would just go right over my head. Still, if you have room for the likes of *me* in your prayers, I’d humbly ask you preferentially included those in more urgent and material distress.

    (Meanwhile, I’ll take your good advice and rest!)

  10. Religious zealots only care about life in the womb, but they couldn’t care less once you’re out. If Sr C van be criticized for being at the Dem convention because they’re murderers, shouldn’t Catholics at the Republican convention be criticized for supporting a pro-death penalty party?
    Sr C represents everything good I was taught as a Catholic. It’s the actions of priests & bishops in their handling of sexual abuse that drove me from the Church. If the Church spent more time worrying about the people that need us to follow Christ’s teaching as opposed to fighting culture wars, then I’d return.
    Until then, God bless Sr C. A true Catholic that cares about the poor and needy first and foremost.

  11. Thank you Matthew and Mark for your articulate rebuttal to the close-minded, hate-mongering right wing extremists who are so easily lead around by the Republican Party.

  12. Why is it that when someone disagrees with a liberal, they are called ‘close-minded, hate mongerers”?  It is quite possible to disagree with another person’s views and not feel hate.  I understand your point of view but do not ascribe to it.  How about some civil discourse.  You’d have a much better chance at changing someone’s mind if you used cogent, articulate arguments rather than stooping to name calling and epithets & generalizations.

  13. Because you are spreading hate in your posts.  Re-read and rethink what YOU have said.  If you are knocking a nun that is devoted to helping the less fortunate because she has chosen a political philosophy that you disagree with, then the devil has truly won, and your the one we need to pray for.  The core of Christianity is tolerance, acceptance and caring for people less fortunate then you.

  14. WHAT!!!!!!!!  The core of Christianity is to treat ALL people with love not only those with whom you agree.  Also, there is more than one way to care for the poor.  Again, disagreeing with someone is not equal to hate nor is it personally ‘knocking’ someone-it is disagreeing.  No devil involved just a different philosophy or is there only one way-your way-to help the poor.  Sounds a bit close-minded.

Related Stories

Did Isaiah really predict the Virgin birth?

(RNS) A new Catholic translation of the Bible tweaks an Old Testament text -- Isaiah 7:14 -- that many Christians consider a prophecy about Jesus’ birth. So, why did they alter a 2,745-year-old prophecy, and does it change what the church teaches about Jesus’ virgin birth? By Daniel Burke.
More | Comments (7)

White Christian voters no longer hold the keys to the White House

 WASHINGTON (RNS) From this election forward, candidates won't be able to win the White House by relying on the white Christian vote, according to a new report. By Lauren Markoe. 
More | Comments (0)

The Ten Worst Stories About the ‘Mormon Moment’

Earlier this week we brought you the 10 best stories about the "Mormon moment." Now, here are the 10 worst, courtesy of MormonVoices. 
More | Comments (24)

Catholic bishops warn Congress not to throw poor off ‘fiscal cliff’

(RNS) As Congress embarks on high-stakes budget negotiations to avoid the “fiscal cliff,” leaders of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops are urging elected officials not to target programs for the poor and instead raise taxes and reduce defense spending. By David Gibson
More | Comments (0)

St. Dorothy Day? Controversial, yes, but bishops push for canonization

BALTIMORE (RNS) The Catholic bishops gathered at their annual meeting couldn’t agree on a statement on the economy, but with a unanimous voice vote on Tuesday they easily backed a measure to push sainthood for Dorothy Day, whose life and work were dedicated to championing the poor. By David Gibson
More | Comments (5)

Sign In



Forgot Password?

You also can sign in with Facebook or Twitter if you've connected your account to them.

Sign In Using Facebook

Sign In Using Twitter