Religion News Service: In-depth. Impartial. Engaged.

Politics » Election

Cardinal Timothy Dolan asks candidates to sign civility pledge

NEW YORK (RNS) Cardinal Timothy Dolan, who sparked controversy by agreeing to deliver the closing blessing at the Republican convention in Tampa this week, on Monday (Aug. 27) drew further attention to his political role by asking both Mitt Romney and Barack Obama to sign a “civility pledge” promoted by a leading conservative Catholic activist.

Show Caption | | Details

Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, has said talks with the White House over a proposed contraception mandate are "going nowhere." Credit: RNS photo by Gregory A. Shemitz

The archbishop of New York wrote to Romney and Obama, as well as their running mates, Paul Ryan and Joe Biden, asking them to sign the “Civility in America” pledge developed by Carl Anderson, head of the powerful Knights of Columbus and a man with long-standing ties to the Republican Party.

Dolan, who is also president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops and the most prominent Catholic churchman in America, said he wanted the candidates to forgo personal attacks and “remain focused on the critical issues facing our nation.”

Neither Dolan nor the Knights of Columbus pledge specifies which issues they meant. But Anderson, whose title is "supreme knight," has been a vocal supporter of the bishops' campaign against the administration’s controversial birth control health insurance mandate. The Knights have also donated millions of dollars to efforts against legalizing same-sex marriage.

For years Anderson has blasted Obama and Biden, who is Catholic, for their support for abortion rights. Just last week in the conservative journal National Review, Anderson penned a blistering critique of Obama for what he said was the president’s decision “to make unrestricted access to abortion a key component of his campaign.”

Anderson is a veteran GOP operative. He spent several years working for Jesse Helms, the late North Carolina senator and ardent culture warrior, before going to work in the Reagan White House. Anderson has influential allies among conservatives in the Vatican and the hierarchy, and the Knights of Columbus can deploy huge sums for – or against – causes they support or oppose.

In closing his letter to the candidates, Dolan promises that if the candidates sign he will “be most happy to be able to convey to Carl Anderson and to the 1.8 million members of the Knights of Columbus, that you have chosen to support this valuable effort.”

Dolan has become increasingly active and visible as the presidential campaign gears up. His decision to deliver the benediction at the GOP convention on Thursday night immediately following Romney’s official nomination was met with sharp rebukes from many who say his appearance will formalize what was seen as the hierarchy’s growing embrace of the Republican ticket.

Whether either of the candidates will sign Anderson’s pledge is unclear. Dolan’s plea comes after a prominent evangelical, Rick Warren, canceled plans for a “civil forum” appearance at his Southern California church by both presidential candidates, saying the nasty political atmosphere had ruined the opportunity.

Sources in both the Romney and Obama campaigns said that in fact neither candidate was planning to attend Warren’s forum. Both campaigns are targeting Catholics in the November election.

 

Topics: Politics, Election
Beliefs: Christian - Catholic
Tags: 2012 presidential election, barack obama, cardinal timothy dolan, carl anderson, civility, knights of columbus, mitt romney

David Gibson

David Gibson is an award-winning religion journalist, author and filmmaker. He writes for RNS and until recently covered the religion beat for AOL's Politics Daily. He blogs at Commonweal magazine, and has written two books on Catholic topics, the latest a biography of Pope Benedict XVI.
View Author Profile

Subscribe to This Blog

You must acquire rights to repost our content. Log in now for permission to download and reprint or repost this article.

Comments

  1. Dearest Cardinal Dolan:
    Your boss was quoted as once saying
    ” What you do for the least of these, you do for me”.
    But your smiling, oh-so-civil face at the Republican Convention
    kinda makes me wonder just who YOU are working for…..

  2. I guess you don’t know that, after agreeing to do the Benediction at the Republican Convention, Cardinal Dolan approached the DNC and stated that he would be glad to do the Benediction at their Convention too.  THEY TURNED HIM DOWN!

  3. When D’s and R’s make pacts, sign agreements or otherwise promise to abstain from
    a process which disturbs some people, guess who is most likely to keep their word, or not.
    D’s are famous for their sly , slick promises and broken words.
    Imagine both sides entering a boxing ring. The R’s have at least one hand bound behind the back, while the D’s have lead filled gloves, and both hands free to pulverize their opponent.
    Prove me wrong, or try!

  4. UNFOUNDED MYTHS:
    1. Republicans are racists more than Democrats…
    2. Democrats care for the poor more than Republicans…
    3. Republicans are more wealthy than Democrats…
    4. Democrats are more “in touch” than Republicans…
    5. All women are Democrats
    6. Only rich white guys are Republicans
    7. Liberals are really “liberal” with their own money
    8. Conservatives are tight-wads
    9. A bigger government is a more compassionate government
    10. The National Debt doesn’t really matter
    11. Printing money won’t impact inflation
    12. Capitalism is bad for the poor
    13. The government creates jobs…

  5. Republican - Democrat….the party is over.  Let’s play nice is a great idea, I just wonder how true to the pact they will be.  Obama’s America 2016 is a must see movie.  The conclusions made are sound.  I viewed it Sunday night and ask now this question; Will heaping coals of kindness tame a venomous snake?
    Who knows.

  6. Just get rid of the tax exemption that is chaining the Catholic Church and prevents her from speaking up for candidates as they support the candidates who FOLLOW THE TEACHINGS OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH!!!!!!!!!  We are being controlled by the government already by this tax exemption!  We have already been silenced!  (BTW Dolan is giving the prayer at the conclusion of the DNC too—are you happy?)

  7. “Civility pledge”???  Is Cardinal Dolan still in 7th grade?  :D There’s nothing ‘civil’ forcing Catholics to pay for a pro-death healthcare system.  The Cardinal is really starting to look very silly to me.

  8. When is he going to ask “Catholic” candidates to stop supporting the butchering of babies? Oh, yeah, “civility” is more important.

  9. I hope the dems will live up to it if they sign on.  I doubt it.  The reps cannot hold back if they don’t.  The whole mess was started by the dems although they won’t admit it.  As far as abortion, Cardinal Dolan has been on the forefront of the battle against it.  There is just so far you can go when you are dealing with people who have been given freedom to choose their own paths in life.  We all have to continue to pray for God’s guidance for ourselves and our leaders to do the right things to get our country back on track.

  10. Dolan,  where do you start to comment about such a groveling irreverent child.  All hell has turned loose on the world and he prattling on “lets talk nice” to mad dog antichrists.  He doesn’t even have a clue what his vocation or faith is about or what’s going on.  He and the American catholic conferences of Bishops have been groveling at the feet of Baby murdering corrupts left wing communist Democrats for decades.  He has dropped his pants in public for Hillary Obama and radical anti human forces of the Satan’s new world order.  He will probably be begging them for a spot at the microphone while they shove him in the prison camp crematory.  How did this pathetic joke even become a priest in the catholic church let alone an Archbishop?  This wanna be lick spittle political player is an embarrassment to our Lord our Faith and Us.

  11. I agree with marynmom - get rid of the tax exemption and you will get rid of the ‘we can’t preach on one candidate or the other’ nonsense the Catholic Church is forced to display when preaching from the Ambo.  You would also get rid of them being bound by this ‘benefit’ they receive from the Government - so they can do more and better works in the communities they serve - as they aren’t bound by any ‘rules’ saying that they can’t do this or that or they’ll lose that benefit. 

    Also - you’ll lose the false ‘requirement’ of people having to register with their local parishes to be considered a parishioner and have a Pastor.  You are a member of your local Parish simply by the fact that you live within the boundaries of the Parish, and are a baptized Catholic.  (Canon Law 96).  When you are told you must register - it is only so they can have ‘more records’ to turn in regarding your donations to them - for the IRS - for tax purposes.  Isn’t giving supposed to be anonymous - why then do they require this?  Because they get the exemption from the Government - if they will report these donations and who makes them (those little envelopes aren’t just for your convenience!) 

    Because of these ‘benefits’ they receive from the Government, the Catholic Church doesn’t really have a leg to stand on when they really need it - NOW - to try to tell you what to do about this next election - to help stop the HHR bill and get it overturned - they can’t really preach from the ambo about this as strongly as the people in Church on Sunday need to hear it to make a difference. 

    Calling meetings about it - helps a little - but those who come - they are already concerned about it - they know whats going on.  But on Sunday - they have a ‘captive audience’ so to speak and they have the opportunity to really capture someone’s attention that may not be aware of how serious this is otherwise - but they can’t really preach on it.

    So when we speak of civility pacts being signed - perhaps if the Church didn’t get this benefit - so they could speak as they need to - there wouldn’t be a need for this ‘pact’.  People need to think more about HOW they act, not what is said, and if they would just put God first, and think - what would I do if Jesus were standing before me right now - BEFORE they act or ‘sling mud’ - the pact wouldn’t be necessary.  If the voters would let the candidates know that they are WATCHING what they are doing and are impacted more by the candidates actions and how they treat the other candidate and other political figures - more than by what is said by them or on their behalf - then the candidates would watch their actions more and know that they are being watched and what they DO is more important than what is said.

  12. Truthseeker.
    Good ideas!  It is time.  When I rallied in March and June for Religious Freedom some of our Catholic priests chose not to stand up and defend our   freedom of conscience from the ambo.  Others including a 84 year old (retired…yea right) priest spoke boldly and clearly about the infringement of the HHS mandate on our freedoms.
    Maybe a tax status change is what is needed…however I cringe at the thought of our govt. using more dollars to support P.P.
    A retired priest…..they are so strong and precious.  They go on working until they are spent.  God bless them.

  13. How about a pledge to eliminate ‘deceit’ and ‘partial truths’ that are often misleading from both campaigns. Then perhaps the ‘truth’ can truly set us free.

Related Stories

White Christian voters no longer hold the keys to the White House

 WASHINGTON (RNS) From this election forward, candidates won't be able to win the White House by relying on the white Christian vote, according to a new report. By Lauren Markoe. 
More | Comments (0)

The Ten Worst Stories About the ‘Mormon Moment’

Earlier this week we brought you the 10 best stories about the "Mormon moment." Now, here are the 10 worst, courtesy of MormonVoices. 
More | Comments (24)

St. Dorothy Day? Controversial, yes, but bishops push for canonization

BALTIMORE (RNS) The Catholic bishops gathered at their annual meeting couldn’t agree on a statement on the economy, but with a unanimous voice vote on Tuesday they easily backed a measure to push sainthood for Dorothy Day, whose life and work were dedicated to championing the poor. By David Gibson
More | Comments (5)

Catholic bishops fail to agree on statement on the economy

BALTIMORE (RNS) A divided Catholic hierarchy on Tuesday (Nov. 13) failed to agree on a statement about the economy after a debate that revealed sharp differences over the kind of social justice issues that were once a hallmark of the bishops’ public profile. By David Gibson.
More | Comments (25)

Chastened Catholic bishops told they have to reform themselves

BALTIMORE (RNS) In the wake of sweeping setbacks to the hierarchy’s agenda on Election Day, New York Cardinal Timothy Dolan on Monday (Nov. 12) told his fellow bishops that they must now look at their own failings, confess their sins and reform themselves if they hope to affect the wider culture. By David Gibson.
More | Comments (8)

Sign In



Forgot Password?

You also can sign in with Facebook or Twitter if you've connected your account to them.

Sign In Using Facebook

Sign In Using Twitter