ATLANTA (RNS) On Thursday (June 21), Catholics across the country will amplify what is an already loud outcry from the hierarchy over the federal government's so-called contraception mandate.
With rallies, marches, lectures and special publications, the U.S. Catholic Bishop's Fortnight for Freedom campaign will seek to galvanize Catholic opposition to President Obama's proposed mandate to require employers -- including religious institutions -- to provide free contraception insurance coverage to employees.
But while Catholic leaders frame the events as a fight for religious liberty, critics see signs of political partisanship and electioneering. Questions over the financing of the bishops' campaign have caused those suspicions to multiply.
"The activities around the Fortnight for Freedom cost money," said Steve Schneck, director of the Institute for Policy Research & Catholic Studies at the Catholic University of America in Washington. "What groups are paying for this, and what's the accountability for that money?"
Those kinds of questions were asked of key Catholic leaders like Baltimore Archbishop William Lori last week as the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops met in Atlanta.
Lori, who heads the bishops' committee on religious liberty, told reporters that gifts "from Catholic groups and foundations" would help sustain the campaign. "The generosity we've experienced has been heartening," he said.
The campaign, Lori said, "is not in any way partisan, either in its spirit or in its funding."
But he has not been specific about all the outside groups providing financial resources, or how much they've contributed.
The Fortnight for Freedom campaign launches with a Mass celebrated by Lori at the nation's first cathedral, the Basilica of the National Shrine of the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary in Baltimore.The two-week push comes as the church is also engaged in a legal battle over what Obama's administration considers a women's health issue.
In March, more than 40 Catholic institutions filed federal lawsuits seeking to block the contraception mandate. Lori told reporters that lawyers were offering pro bono assistance to the Catholic legal effort.
Critics like Schneck say many of the questions regarding the funding of the Fortnight for Freedom campaign center on private Catholic groups.
"The Knights of Columbus are clearly one of the major sources of funding (against the mandate), as well as other fraternal organizations," Schneck said.
The Knights of Columbus, a Catholic charitable group based in New Haven, Conn., says it's the world's largest lay Catholic organization. Knights of Columbus life insurance sales neared $8 billion in 2010, and last year, it contributed $158 million to charity. In the last decade, the Knights have donated more than $1 billion to charity.
The group's 2010 tax forms show that the Knights gave more than $3 million to the Vatican that year, nearly $2 million to the U.S. bishops conference and $25,000 to the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, which has guided much of the legal action against the contraception mandate.
The group must disclose more recent donations in its 2011 tax forms. But Andrew Walther, a Knights of Columbus spokesman, said the group has asked for an extension in filing the documents, making them unavailable until the fall.
In 2010, the Knights were also generous with their contributions to individual bishops, doling out nearly $350,000 for a variety of programs in various dioceses. Of that, $248,700, or 71 percent, went to Lori's former Diocese of Bridgeport.
Lori — who is the man most directly in charge of the Fortnight for Freedom campaign — has been the Supreme Chaplain of the Knights of Columbus since 2005.
The Knights did not respond to requests for an interview about the organization's involvement with the bishops' campaign, but the organization has dedicated recent issues of its monthly magazine to the topic of religious liberty.
John Gehring, Catholic program director at Faith in Public Life, a liberal advocacy group in Washington, said while the Knights' charitable works was "commendable ... its leadership has steered a fraternal organization into political waters in ways that should raise questions."
Asked by reporters in Atlanta last week if the Knights' involvement in the religious liberty campaign introduces at least the perception of partisanship, Lori said no. Other groups have contributed to the campaign, he said, mentioning Our Sunday Visitor and the Order of Malta.
"Think of what the Knights of Columbus does for the Catholic Church and for many other humanitarian causes," he said. "To try to say that is in some way partisan is … an injustice."
(Tim Townsend writes for St. Louis Post-Dispatch in St. Louis.)
KRE/LEM END TOWNSEND




Vance Mann | Jun 20, 2012 | 9:47pm
Sounds like the RC bishops are a medieval men’s club grasping for power & control while holding fast to an outdated monarchical system of government.. Will they succeed?
jz | Jun 21, 2012 | 9:36am
Wow huge surprise here! A solidly Catholic organization (the Knights) is donating heavily to a cause to protect religious liberty, with the current attack aimed squarely at - get this - Catholics! Remember that it was Obama who brought on this fight, not Catholics. Obama changed established precedent via governmental fiat by declaring which organizations are religious enough to be worthy of religious freedom (parishes, diocese) and which are not (Catholic hospitals/schools). Those who believe the “Church” consists only of diocese and local parishes have a severely warped view of Christianity.
Steve Schneck should be ashamed of himself. He is clearly insinuating the Church and the financial supporters of Fortnight for Freedom are involved in some sort of impropriety or devious behavior…Where’s the evidence Mr. Schneck? Can you say calumny?
Ralph | Jun 21, 2012 | 10:59am
The Vatican has been a monarchy for over 1000 years, they have had a relatively stable government, and the Papal States were reduced to its present form only after a foreign invasion from the House of Savoy (another monarchy). They seem to have been fairly stable, and no one seems to be complaining of human rights violations. What is it that democracies with rampant corruption and inequality is to teach them?
So, the leaders of a religious organization want to maintain control over the organizations they lead: outrageous.
Be wary of the Knights of Columbus. These guys have been supporting charities and the churches for decades. But it was all a sham. They really are part of a Jesuit plot, and their ultimate goal is the overthrow of the American government. Isn’t that obvious? Don’t be fooled by their good manners, charity and good works! I am grateful that this article finally opened my eyes.
Patrick Lee | Jun 21, 2012 | 2:47pm
The government is attempting to coerce Catholic organizations to be the purveyors of an ideology they object to on religious grounds. The Church does not impose its teachings on anyone. Since when did objecting to being forced to pay for something that violates one’s conscience become an attempt to impose on others one’s beliefs? This story distorts the basic issue.
Jim McCrea | Jun 21, 2012 | 3:00pm
When the bishops demonstrate concern for religious freedom within the Catholic church, then I might be sympathetic to their moaning and groaning. Until then, we all need to remember what St. Ignatius of Antioch is reputed to have said: ” A bishop never more resembles Jesus Christ than when he has his mouth shut. “
Ralph | Jun 21, 2012 | 5:27pm
“When the bishops demonstrate concern for religious freedom within the Catholic church, then I might be sympathetic to their moaning and groaning.”
Exactly, they shouldn’t have kept quiet while the Catholic militia arrested the dissenting American nuns and sent them to Castel Sant’Angelo to be tortured until they could extract a confession. I should expect the burning of dissenting Catholics anytime now. Who do these bishops think they are? Do they think that they have any authority within the Church?
These Catholic bishops seem only to be concerned about the religious liberty of Christians in the U.S., Asia, the Middle East, Europe and the Americas. Poor Catholic dissenters, no one in the Church defends them from all the violence that these bishops are inflicting on them
Oh give me a break! | Jun 22, 2012 | 4:41am
This article’s author lies and distorts facts surrounding thestory; his descriptions are biased, his conclusions unsupported.
E.g., “President Obama’s proposed mandate to require employers—including religious institutions—to provide free contraception insurance coverage to employees.” -First, there’s nothing “proposed” about the HHS mandate; it is law. Second, since the mandated insurance must cover also cover abortifacients and sterilization, it is broader than merely requiring “contraception” coverage.
Furthermore, how can the author conclude that support from Catholic groups (KofC) for a Catholic event promoting values consistent with Catholic teachings makes the event partisan??? Is it any more partisan than ANY Catholic event, in that is supports the tenets of Catholicism? In fact this 2-bit author offers NO SUPPORT for his conclusions; only vague quotes from critics who themselves provide no support.
Sloppy journalism. (Shame on you, Tim.) Why does RNS carry this garbage??
Rev. Albert W. Kovacs, UCC Pastor | Jun 26, 2012 | 1:30pm
Nothing new here. It was in an Anglican Church in Virginia that Patrick Henry declared:Give me freedom or give me death! ... It was in a Reformed Church in Debrecen that Louis Kossuth declared independence for Hungary from the Habsburg Emperor of Austria. ... It was in churches in America that slavery was openly disavowed. ... Protestant colleges like Geneva, Grove City, Liberty, Brigham Young, and many others don’t want their freedoms trampled by government fiat. HHS and Obama are led by the nose by the hand of Planned Parenthood and its cohorts in the multi-million dollar abortion industry. It’s all about elections and money! ... Kudos to our allies in the RC Church leading the fight for religious freedom in America today..
Joseph J Marotta, MD | Jun 27, 2012 | 3:51pm
I have been extremely disappointed in the way the Knights of Columbus, the USCCB and CRS distribute their wealth. $8 billion worth of insurance profits is a huge amount of money. The KofC is chartered to act at the behest of the Bishops for the service of the poor and needy. As a former Knight, it is shameful to see the organization stock pile its finances and distribute it out to programs that don’t really foster the type of activity I would consider appropriate. Thats why I am no longer involved in their scam.
I wish someone would do an expose on where all of these “Catholic” funds are going and at least let the members of the Church know how their donations are spent when they hand over their hard earned dollars to organizations like the KofC, CRS, etc.