Religion News Service: In-depth. Impartial. Engaged.

Culture » Social Issues

COMMENTARY: No man (or nation) is an island

NEW YORK (RNS) Manhattan was a traffic nightmare as the United Nations General Assembly was in session and security precautions ramped up.

Iran's president gave his usual insulting address. Israel's prime minister volleyed with dire warnings of Iran's nuclear-weapons intentions. Not much was expected of a session that was more political podium than problem solving.

But the event did underscore a reality that Americans often overlook: Not everything is about us. The world doesn't turn on a politician's latest line of attack. The fine points of Obamacare or Mitt Romney's 1040 or Paul Ryan's budget? Meh.

On the one hand, this unconcern is nothing unusual; hometown affairs are always of far more interest to locals than to anyone else. I could go months without caring about Kate Middleton's topless cavorting or political show trials in Beijing.

On the other hand, it is good to be reminded that we are one piece of a vast global mosaic. We connect with others but aren't necessarily the center.

Rather than proceed as a nation-level version of the "narcissistic princess" -- as one reviewer labeled tell-all author Monica Lewinsky -- we should pay more attention to the connections among us.

It matters whether we show respect to other peoples. It matters whether we play fair when our interests converge. It matters whether we overcome our bullying instinct when our interests collide. It matters whether we preserve our own freedom by the sword or by affirming others' rights to self-determination.

In our volatile, ambiguous and interconnected world, raw nationalism has become a danger to civilization. Literally so, as horrific weapons pass into highly unstable hands guided by the least enlightened of tribal and national instincts.

Learning to respect other peoples, and to imagine their needs as legitimate as our own, is a critical component of modern wisdom.

Religious fervor isn't a new threat to the human condition – indeed, it might be the oldest threat – but lately religious fervor has morphed into a religious extremism that has sent violence hopscotching around the globe in search of soft targets.

If we can't find common ground, we risk global annihilation.

Rather than press on toward destruction, it's time we learned the ancient Stoic principle called “adiaphora,” or “things indifferent.” It states that some things matter more than others, and some things don't matter much at all. To Christians, for example, the resurrection of Jesus does matter; what time the Sunday service is held doesn't matter.

Adiaphora was presented to me as explaining Anglicanism's preference for compromise, for the middle way, for loving persons more than right opinion. It explains the thought gap between fundamentalist and progressive Christianity, two sincere and well-grounded schools of faith that differ over absolutes and right opinion.

The challenge, of course, is to discern what matters and what doesn't. Adiaphora's answer is to say it's all relative. What matters for you might not matter for me. When our interests collide, your being right or my being right won't matter as much as our being one in God. We are likely to find more truth in forgiveness and forbearance than in consistency and self-crafted righteousness.

As soft and soupy as it might sound, humanity's future is at stake. The time has come for earnest people to put down their doctrines and swords and to join hands.

(Tom Ehrich is a writer, church consultant and Episcopal priest based in New York. He is the author of "Just Wondering, Jesus" and founder of the Church Wellness Project. His website is www.morningwalkmedia.com. Follow Tom on Twitter @tomehrich.)

 

Topics: Culture, Social Issues
Tags: tom ehrich

You must acquire rights to repost our content. Log in now for permission to download and reprint or repost this article.

Related Stories

COMMENTARY: We aren’t at their mercy as much as they (or we) think we are

NEW YORK (RNS) A lot of money goes into compelling our behavior, not liberating it. And into pleasing the powerful, not disrupting them. But I sense the tide of personal potency is turning. By Tom Ehrich. About 700.
More | Comments (1)

COMMENTARY: Thanksgiving every day

(RNS) In the afterglow, I give thanks for Thanksgiving Day. It might be our most spiritual holiday. We did nothing remarkable, and yet we sampled the cornucopia that makes life matter: love, patience, giving to others. By Tom Ehrich.
More | Comments (0)

COMMENTARY: I have seen the problem, and it is us

NEW YORK (RNS) Establishment Christianity has taken inordinate satisfaction in our occasional mission work among the needy, but not challenged each other to seek transformation of life. When we should have been proclaiming the gospel that Jesus actually preached, we were building an institution that depended on not offending the wealthy. By Tom Ehrich. 
More | Comments (0)

COMMENTARY: Seeking clarity

NEW YORK (RNS) The ``October trifecta'' that touched my life -- my father's death, surgery and the unprecedented destruction of Hurricane Sandy -- did what traumatic events often do: they left me emotionally fatigued and ready for some fresh clarity, fresh perspective and fresh prioritizing. By Tom Ehrich.
More | Comments (1)

After Sandy, New Yorkers and New Jerseyites showed “this is what adults do”

NEW YORK (RNS) After the most dreadful political season in memory, I took heart as leaders stepped up to lead after Hurricane Sandy and as adults stepped up to do what adults do. Those who have actual responsibilities carried them out, while those who lust for power were ignored. By Tom Ehrich.
More | Comments (0)

Sign In



Forgot Password?

You also can sign in with Facebook or Twitter if you've connected your account to them.

Sign In Using Facebook

Sign In Using Twitter