Religion News Service: In-depth. Impartial. Engaged.

Blogs » Omid Safi - What Would Muhammad Do?

What Would Muhammad Do? has moved: Click here to read the latest posts

It is time (and past time) to Occupy Mecca—to save Mecca.

It is time, and past time, to Occupy Mecca.

I am adamantly not talking about a disaster US occupation, a la Iraq and Afghanistan.

What I am calling for is nothing less than millions of faithful pilgrims saving Mecca from destruction.

I would call the destruction imminent, except that it is not imminent.  It has already happened.

No, it’s not the Americans, or the Israelis, who would be destroying Mecca.
It’s the so-called Guardians of the two holy sites (Mecca and Medina), the Saudi royal elites, who have negligently stood by over the last two decades as the majority of holy sites in these two most sacred Muslim cities have been destroyed, sacrificed to the false gods of modernization, capitalism, and progress.

Saudi Wahhabis have a long history of destroying shrines, including those of the family of the Prophet in Saudi Arabia and Iraq.  

The historical cemeteries of the families and companions of the Prophet, which used to look like this, now look like this:





The graves of the descendants of the Prophet now look like dusty rubbles, with only stones to identify them.    Armed Saudi policemen beat away and arrest pilgrims who stop to offer their respect.

The early Wahhabis even had designed to destroy the Prophet’s Mosque in Medina, as they assumed that Muslims who were offering blessings and salutations on the Prophet (as the Qur’an commands them to do!) were in fact idolaters. 

The Saudis have destroyed or bulldozed some 300 sacred sites and shrines in Mecca and Medina in creating what many are calling the new “Las Vegas.”

Here is some of what the local experts in Saudi Arabia have to say about this cultural and architectural genocide: 

"No one has the balls to stand up and condemn this cultural vandalism," says Dr Irfan al-Alawi who, as executive director of the Islamic Heritage Research Foundation, has fought in vain to protect his country's historical sites. "We have already lost 400-500 sites. I just hope it's not too late to turn things around."And here is what a Saudi Architect, Dr. Angwai, has to say:

"The house where the Prophet received the word of God is gone and nobody cares," says Dr Angawi, a Saudi architect. "I don't want trouble. I just want this to stop."

The Gulf Institute estimates that 95% of the religious structures in Mecca have been destroyed in the last two decades.

The rush to build 5-star hotels for the richest of the pilgrims comes at the expense of historical mosques, shrines, cemeteries, and homes that are being bulldozed one after another to make room for the new Hiltons hotels and Channel (and similar) shopping malls.    Many Muslims all over the world see the crass commercialism of these sites as a gross violation of the radical egalitarianism of Islamic teachings so beautifully emphasized in the Hajj pilgrimage. 

What was intended to be an occasion to symbolize the unity of humanity standing before the Divine in the most basic of garments is now turned by the Saudi royal elite (working in tandem with Wahhabi clerics) into an occasion to create the world’s largest market for spiritual tourism.

The new Clock Tower in Mecca dwarfs the significance and centrality of the Ka’ba, which has been seen by Muslims as the very center of the Earth and the Temple of God built by Abraham.

The sacred places rooted in Muslim memory have literally been turned into toilets.   The house of the Prophet’s wife, Khadhija (may God be pleased with her) was recently turned into a row of latrines.  

The Wahhabis don’t hate all buildings.    They are spending more than a billion dollars to build the world’s largest tower
This in an age where one out of every five of God’s creation lives on a dollar a day.    Surely we could find a place for this one billion:  the wrinkled stomachs of the poorest of God’s children.

For a (polemical) documentary of destruction, see this.

It is time and past time to start an Occupy Mecca movement, to save what’s left of Mecca and Medina. 

What we would be saving would not just be the last remaining pieces of the Islamic architecture of Mecca and Medina, it would be our own dignity as Muslims.


Tags: bulldoze, commercial, las vegas, mecca, medina, saudi, shrines, wahhabi


  1. Beloved Omid: There will come a time when Muslims will recognize that turning towards the physical Kaba or kissing the black stone is less enriching than turning to the Kaba within and kissing those who are most deprived. Love, light and shadow, Jalaledin

  2. Omid: when was the last time you were in Makkah and Madina?



  4. I was recently there and witnessed all those distractions and building of luxurious hotels. Not to say a thing about the “wonderful” behavior of locals; that was not even close to the teachings and practice of our beloved prophet.


  5. From a social worker’s viewpoint, this appears to be a religous ethical dilemma. How to provide access to Mecca for the world’s fastest growing religion? If modernizations did not occur, who would decide who can make the haj during the pr…escribed month in the midst of overcrowded and unsanitary conditions? On the other side, if Mecca is bull-dozed to make a giant hotel, what will be left of the holy site besides the Holy Kaba? I meekly suggest that the clerics consider social solutions, such as proclaiming pilgrimage during other times to have as much significance, etc. What do you suiggest professor Safi? Don’t you think something has to change?

  6. With all my critique of Saudi’s policies of making it more like a business center than spiritual site, I must appreciate their efforts in keeping it clean with the most modern facilities available. I was very impressed by the rapid and frequent cleaning by efficient team of workers equipped using latest technology. and BTW I dont think Professor Safi can change the prescribed month smile for Haj.

  7. They should have not placed all the hotels and malls so close to the Haram/Kabbah. 
    It would have been better if all of the hotels/mall were build like 1 mile away and have trams/trains/rails running continuously to/from the hotels to the Haram.  This would have keep all the shoppers and “hustle & bustle” separated from poeple worshipping and praying.

  8. Religion is used to fulfill the political agenda of ‘Wahabis’. Unless religion is understood as re-legion & separate from country law, culture & traditions, it is not possible to save Mecca or Madina. Pl share to understand your religion, ‘TRUE ESSENCE OF RELIGION’,

  9. there is no doubt that development of facilities are required for the growing multitude of pilgrims but not at the cost of the destruction of the very sites that are part of their legacy and heritage. Look at the western world and how they have preserved their historical sites, yet manage to develop the much need infra-structure.

  10. God forbid we Muslims ever thought archeological expeditions of the holy land (a la Israel/Palestine) would be fruitful endeavors for deepening our understanding of our tradition.

    It is so sad these links to our Prophet and this period are gone for good.

    Great post, btw.

  11. Any monotheistic faith that forbids idolatry is going to have periodic outbreaks of iconoclastic vandalism under the guise of “purification of the faith”. Christianity got this drive from Judaism, as did Islam. Even Eastern Orthodoxy had its iconoclastic periods. And Protestantism in its Calvinist form destroyed every image in sight. Even Henry VIII, as “Catholic” as he was, burned the shrines of the saints in England.

    Given Islam’s deep and powerful suspicion of anything like “shirk”, and of images, this is not surprising.

    Even the linkage of religious fervor with the exhibition of wealth is not new. All the English churches that had their statues of Christ, the Virgin and the Saints removed were then filled up with the tombs (and statues) of the nobility.

    Iconoclasm is virus within prophetic monotheism.

  12. May Allah grant me bulldozing those shops and hotels around ka3aba wa ‘salla Allah 3ala seyidinna Muhammad.

Sign In

Forgot Password?

You also can sign in with Facebook or Twitter if you've connected your account to them.

Sign In Using Facebook

Sign In Using Twitter